2Bully, I agree with Lisa, and Cathy's post. You can take a so/so dog and with enough training you can put a title on it. I have also seen it done several times. Go to a trial and see how many are competing on their own field, with their club decoys, you will be amazed. Of this group see how many are only competing at this venue, due to the extra crutch/advantage. I am not knocking them for it per-say, it is a start, and no matter what it takes commitment to title a dog from the handler. Again though as a breeding prospect it does have its huge disadvantage.
I stated above I choose a dog based off of it's pedigree. I have also worked some and seen many of the dogs in Envy's pedigree work in person. I truly originally wanted a pup which went back to double bred Oden X Maarley daughter bred to Waldo to work with, I found one Richard's Phoenix she was started with a Sch BH, but I didn't reach a deal in time and she now belongs to a breeder in Sweden. I have no problem with this due to I love the pedigree of Envy, and I wanted something which matched up at least to start it off well with malo, but I will only find out if she makes it in time. WORK COMES FIRST, and to me work is everything.
Lisa, I wouldn't worry about me being offended by your comments I believe they are well thought out and sound similar to my own a few years back. I am always researching, I am just as happy sitting through a seminar from a qualified canine behaviorist as I am a working seminar these days, well almost. I use a lot of conditioning with a pup not necessarily to desensitize everything, but so I can start the dog younger. We (my girlfriend and I) started her Mal early in a similar way. She is just at 12 months, I thought she was 14 months until I spoke with my girlfriend today; woman always remember everything, totally off subject. We are deciding if we want to go for her PDC at the PSA trial latter this month. If it where not for the change in training style's we may have held on to her for a year before we started her, and not set to compete as we are close to now. All the conditioning, and imprinting, yes they will help with distractions, and it will help mask somethings, but only just as much as any good trainer, decoy or handler will do in training. There will always be those dogs which title, but truly lack courage, just as much as there will always be that hard, prey driven monster sitting in someones backyard, or laying on there couch 20+ pounds over weight.
When you condition and Imprint at an early stage, I find it an easier way to choose if this dog fits what I want at a much younger age. I will wash a dog out, it sucks you have started a bond, but truly I took in the dog as a working prospect. The worse that happens to this wash out is someone receives a young dog, with good OB, socialized, a lack of hard prey drive, all things which make a great pet quality dog after they are sterilized. I do not wish to wait until a dog is 2 years of age to decide if it has the qualities I desire, I would rather find out much earlier.
I condition and Imprint to test my prospect. I do test to cover all areas I will later work the dog in; OB, agility, and bite work. This is all performed under the use of lure rewards, whether it is a ball, treats, or tug. I want a dog with that IT quality. No matter how much conditioning I do I can not get that IT quality. This is only inside the dog, but I will work to the best of my ability to pull out that IT if I can. I love a hard tough dog, one that after a decoy is done working it they grit there teeth due to the damage the dog left them with and say, "I loved that dog, he/she is one tough SOB." An example of this is I decoyed for the Western States Police Canine Association, police K9 trial on Saturday. There where 54 dogs in the protection phase of the trial some very hard dogs, and some well lets be nice and say not so hard. I will not give out any departments but there was a dog which caught me on a flee with my arms tucked to not present an arm, this dog came up and took a bite to the right side of my back fully, leaving one hell of a bruise and a puncture wound threw the suit. It hurt like hell, and I loved this Malinois. Latter in the day same scenario, I worked a dog which followed me barking, so I put the dog in some pray and gave it a bite. You could not give me this dog for free, and it is a working dog on the street, scary for the officer. I hope this dog is strictly for NARC. The last dog was conditioned for schutzhund which was obvious by the bark and hold, and only wanting to bite the left forearm. No matter, how much imprinting or conditioning you do, there was nothing which would have made this dog strong for the street, or given it that IT QUALITY.
There are a lot of trainers which use imprinting and conditioning to enhance the learning behavior in the early stages of development. Just look at the trial results for Schutzhund USA, NARA, or Mondio USA you will see countless dogs coming from either Ot Vitosha, or Loups De Soleil. Both of these kennels integrate a lot of imprinting and conditioning, and emphasize this to there students. I agree this is only a philosophy on learning behavior, but all training is based on philosophies, some work better then others for each individual.
I do not believe breeding is hurt, if one continues to breed for the ability the dog versus the title on a dog. I would discourage anyone for breeding to a dog due to his/her title, but at the same time I would gladly lend assistance to someone to assist in achieving there set goal with there canine prospect. When it comes to if imprinting or conditioning hides a weak dog, possibly, but so does good training, good decoys, and good handling. I believe this can disguise more then imprinting or conditioning does. So yes the example of the stick, I can take a dog to the field, and yes others may take some time to work the stick through several sessions and my dog may do extremely well the first time, as I see it cu dos to me, because a good decoy will do the same with some sessions on a dog, without imprinting to the extent I do. Imprinting, and conditioning are tools, no different the, good training, good decoys, and good handling. We all use crutches or we would train without any type of reward, and zero compulsion (no verbal, correction collars or E-collars), the day training can be done this way sign me up I am very interested.
I believe but do not agree with, the only way to get the exact answer to the best hard dogs, is to hold onto each dog for a prescribed age, test them exactly the same, by the same decoy. The dog can have no imprinting, this means no socialization, along with work in OB, bite work, etc. This would be the ultimate test for breeding. I would never want to see something like this happen though, because it is not humane to the animal, I enjoy working my dog, plus the good dogs will never go the distance they could have gone. It may take away the weak dog, genetically, but I believe as handlers it is are job to do are homework, at the same time remembering all dogs produce dogs which lack the drive for sport work especially in the bully breeds.
This is for the newbies, if you are looking for a dog for sport-work RESEARCH from the dogs to your breeder. If you want a sport dog do not purchase a pup from someone which works and breeds for catch dogs, and to the contrary the best sport dog doesn't mean it can catch a cold if it tried. Look at breeders with experience in the field you want to try, they hopefully breed for these qualities. Do not stop there research those who have purchased dogs from them, and work them. I n the bully world people like to pass high drive around like it exists everywhere, BS, it doesn't. Just because they worked there dog once and it bit the rag, sleeve or suit does not make it high drive. I at times wonder if HIGH DRIVE IS DETERMINED BY HOW FAST A DOG RUNS IN ITS BACKYARD after talking to some breeders. Do your research, the more you do the better it will pay off, do not be afraid to call people with known names in bully breeds they are just people no different then you. One thing with all of us on here we love to talk dogs or we wouldn't be here, just remember that before you research.
Lisa thank you for your response, and I will put it back to you, I hope none of this offended you. This is always the one thing I hate about leaving things on paper, you do not get the opportunity to speak directly with someone, so you can not read there facial expressions to see if they may take offense. Keep bulldogging, and keep up with your responses they are important for others to hear. Discussion on dogs when open and productive just make us all better dog people. To anyone reading these posts I hope this was productive just as well as all posts pertaining to this have been for me.