The grading system we use here doesn't account for a few of the ingredients that are included in this kibble, and doesn't address the production process specifically in regards to baking vs. extruding (for which I gave it the full 5 points because their process very different, but better imho) that this company uses.
I also added 4 points for the 4(!!) different types of eggs that are included (chicken, duck, pheasant & quail), including them in the "different animal protein" category. I don't know if others do it that way.
The website also does not specifically say whether the meat ingredients are organic or hormone/antibiotic free, so I emailed them and I'll revise this score based on their answer. If they are organic or hormone/antibiotic free, the score will be higher, obviously.
So with that in mind, the food rated a 122, which ties for the highest (I believe) with DVP Natural Balance. I like this food MUCH better, however, as I believe in the high protein/fat low carbohydrate (filler) concept, mimicing a raw diet (and I just don't have the time or the inclination to feed raw).
Maddi is currently on Innova Evo and Chance is on DVP Natural Balance. Personally, I'll be switching both of my dogs to this food ASAP - as in, I'll be buying a bag tomorrow. My local supplier carries it (Lee's Feed in Shingle Springs is hands down the BEST feed store I've ever seen).