I never understood this whole paper training thing. Why not just make the dog go outside? If it refuses to eliminate outside for whatever reason, bring it in the house and put it in the crate. That way it will be forced to be uncomfortable by holding it in unless they want to lay in their own urine and feces which most dogs won't do. Eventually it will learn it has no choice but to go outside. Sounds like the dog is training its owner. Who wants smelly urine and feces in their house anyway? I certainly wouldn't!!!